Best Bike Seat for Overweight Bike Riders [2021 Guide]

| |

Best Bike Seat for Overweight Bike Riders [2021 Guide]

As an overweight person, it is sometimes a challenge to find the most comfortable bike seat. And if you have ever ridden in the wrong seat, you know that there are some VERY good reasons why you would want a more comfortable bike seat.

As an overweight person, it’s common knowledge that you have some extra weight and pressure.

This causes pressure in the perineum (the area between the anus and groin), which affects circulation and leads to potential health problems such as nerve damage, numbness and even impotency in men.

The bottom line?

Finding the right bike seat as a heavy rider goes beyond comfort and affects your health in a various serious way.

In this article, I give you my recommendations for most comfortable bike seats for overweight people. I also explain what exactly you are to look for in a bike seat to maximize comfort.

So let’s get right to it!

In a Rush? Here are Our Top Picks

What Makes a Bicycle Seat Comfortable?

There are several variable that affect whether a bike seat is comfortable, including cushioning and width of the saddle. We’ll discuss all of the main aspects of the best bike seat for overweight riders below.

But if you’re in a rush, here is a great primer on bicycle seats and what makes them comfortable.

Cushioning

We all know that cushioning is usually associated with comfort. And with bikes it’s no different.

In the bike world, there are two main types of cushioning: gel and foam. The type of gel you prefer will depend on the type of riding you do.

Gel cushioning is generally preferred by more casual riders. They conform a little better to your body, although they won’t last as long as foam.

Foam cushioning is preferred by more serious riders. It will tend to give you more support, is firmer and is ideal if you are going on longer rides.

And we can’t forget the last option, which is no cushion at all!

Although this seems extremely uncomfortable, many riders actually prefer no cushion, especially since the seats tend not to get as hot. If you live in an especially hot climate, you may want to consider no cushion.

Saddle Width

Saddle with is super critical because a saddle too wide (or narrow) is going to cause you serious discomfort.

The most important thing is to get the proper saddle width for YOUR body. Specifically you want to measure your sit bone, technically known as ischial tuberosities.

Luckily this is a pretty straightforward process and most bike shops will be able to measure your seat bone width.

Once you have your seat bone measurements, you can always look at the spec pages for bike saddles to get an idea of if the seat is right for you. But remember, saddles come in all different curvatures and levels of padding, so there is nothing that beats actually sitting on the saddle before purchasing.

Saddle Shape

Generally, the way you ride and your individual athleticism and flexibility will determine the best shape saddle for you. For instance, a flat saddle mostly suits riders who make minimal movements (in their upper body) when cycling.

On the other hand, a saddle which is lightly curved suits intermediate riders, while round saddles are recommended for cyclists who move their torsos a lot while riding.

Saddle Covers

Saddles covers are what you will be feeling against your bottom while you ride. So this is obviously something you should give at least some thought to.

Saddles covers will generally come in three different materials: synthetic, leather, and cotton. Most bikes will have synthetic covers, and this is usually fine if you are a casual rider.

Leather covers are the premium option, and although it will take some time to break in, over time they tend to provide more comfort. The main downside is that leather covers are not waterproof, so if you are in a rainy climate this might not be the best option.

And finally cotton covers. In terms of breaking these seat covers in, it is right in the middle between synthetic (no break in period) and leather (long break in period). Cotton covers are soft and will offer you a relatively comfortable ride.

Saddle/Seat Pads

For people who need a little extra cushion, saddle pads are a great option. They go right over your seat and add additional cushioning. Saddle pads also make the seat slightly wider and more comfortable in most cases.

We especially recommend you use a saddle pad if you’ve had a history of lower back injuries.

Most Comfortable Bike Seats for Overweight Riders

Now that you know some of the components of what makes a bicycle seat comfortable, here are our choices for best bike seats for overweight bicyclists.

1. Bikeroo Oversized Comfort Bike Seat: Best Overall

Bikeroo Oversized Comfort Bike Seat
12,109 Reviews
Bikeroo Oversized Comfort Bike Seat

  • Comfortable bike seat with extra padding and elastomer spring suspension; spares you from aches and pains as it divides the pressure when used as a stationary exercise, indoor, or outdoor bike seat.
  • Tested by more than 25.000 cycling enthusiasts, our customers believe that the soft padding and extra wide construction makes it great for Indoor and Outdoor bikes.
  • Bonus Bikeroo Accessories: Waterproof bicycle cover, easy-to-use tools to mount, universal bicycle seat adapter, mounting instructions, and an ebook filled with additional info.
  • The universal mount will fit your ride whether it is a cruiser, mountain, road city, fixed gear, or touring bike.

If you still struggle with occasional discomfort even after trying some of the recommended saddles, then it could be time to try this bike seat a leading bicycle seat for heavy riders

Indeed, Bikeroo Oversized Comfort is our choice for best bike seat for overweight riders, and for good reason. It has long been rated as one of the most comfortable bike seats in the market today because of its extra padding coupled with a dual spring suspension.

It should, therefore, enable you to finally forget about pain and soreness whether you are using it as a stationary seat or as an outdoor padded bike seat.

The oversized bike seat is ergonomic meaning after the initial brief break-in period, it adapts perfectly to your body making for maximum enjoyment when riding.

It’s especially good for oversize riders because its width distributes pressure uniformly on the wider sitting area allowing you to enjoy your trips without back pain.

Its universal design makes it suitable for almost any bike out there- road city bikes, cruisers, fixed gear, mountain bikes, and touring.

More to this, and unlike some competitors, it’s super-easy to mount thanks to its standard rails mounting system and the universal saddle adapter.

Lastly, with it, you can even ride during a storm as it comes with a waterproof cover.

Features    

  • Thick padding
  • Dual spring suspension
  • Extra wide ergonomic design
  • Waterproof seat cover
  • Universal seat adapter
  • Standard rails

Pros

  • The standard rails, the accompanying eBook, and universal adapter make It’s so easy to mount on any bike.
  • The seat cover is water proof so riders can ride even during a storm without drenching.
  • This oversized bike seat has heavy duty padding and the spring suspension.
  • Its wider design enables it to share weight uniformly across the surface thus delivering great support for overweight riders.

Cons

  • The springs may sometimes become a bit squeaky especially when pedaling aggressively.

Verdict

The thick and excessive soft foam padding plus the dual spring suspensions make this oversized saddle one of the best bicycle seat

Its ability to distribute pressure across the surface and to help avoid back pains is unmatched.

2. INBIKE Most Comfortable Bicycle Seat: Most Comfortable Bike Seat for Long Trips

INBIKE Most Comfortable Bicycle Seat
381 Reviews
INBIKE Most Comfortable Bicycle Seat
  • Size 10.6"*7.9", suitable for cruiser bikes, comfortable bikes
  • Surface microfiber artificial leather is of wear resistant, smooth and...
  • Inner high density perforating foam plus dual springs (covered by rubber rings...
  • Middle groove is helpful to air ventilation and sweat releasing,good for cyclers...
  • Universal design, can work on any standard seat posts, a free wrench for you to...

Looking at the Inbike bicycle seat the first time, you can clearly see that this super wide bike seat was purpose-designed for a big man.

The construction and the material used make it much better to ride on and it should thus make butt pain a thing of the past.

First, we liked the front design- it’s narrower, just the way preferred by overweight guys because it minimizes friction especially whether out on a leisurely ride or a competition.

Then, the quality of the microfiber artificial leather used on the surface is up there with the best and again purposed to make the saddle special for big men and women- it’s not only wear resistant but also super-smooth and non-scratching.

We also love the high density foam padding on the inner side plus the dual springs…the two creates a superb buffer making it shock proof, stable, and enjoyable when riding over bumps or uneven terrain.

And if you tend to frequently embark on long, adventurous expeditions, the middle groove will come in handy as it improves air circulation and in releasing sweat.

Overall, this is an awesome option for owners of cruiser bikes who are fond of long distance riding and are tired of the persistent hip pain.

Features

  • Microfiber artificial leather surface
  • High-density foam
  • Dual springs
  • Middle groove
  • Universal design

Pros

  • The padding, duals springs, and narrow front make this seat super comfortable
  • It’s easy to adjust so you can easily identify your most comfortable pose
  • This saddle is very well-constructed from the top, the underside padding, and the groove- everything looks well planned.
  • It performs as well as the high-end saddles but at a fraction of the cost.

Cons

  • Considering that they’re plastic, the suspensions may not last for long

Verdict

The Inbike is bigger in and out, more comfortable, and very well-constructed.

It should deliver a different riding experience.

3. Zacro Gel Bike Saddle: Best Bike Seat for Overweight Off-Roaders

Zacro Gel Bike Saddle
778 Reviews
Zacro Gel Bike Saddle
  • PU and Dual-density gel foam padding is soft and elastic that save you from...
  • Carbon steel coil dual spring suspension helps smooth out bumps.
  • Thicker soft saddle make you feel more comfortable.
  • Universal design installs on any standard seat post.
  • Easy mounting with the help of Zacro wrench.

The Zacro Gel Bike Saddle a very functional saddle- way better than the hard seats that come with bikes.

Gel padded, extra thick and oversized, this saddle is primed to serve as the most comfortable mountain bike seat as it conforms to your body shape a lot better than other seats.

The PU material makes the saddle to look more elegant apart from enhancing its quality and is one of the few saddles that feel right without any “break in” period.

The highly-elastic foam is resilient and gives a better cycling feeling under pressure while its coil dual spring suspensions help smoothen out bumps delivering an unforgettable time regardless of the terrain.

Unlike the Inbike which is recommended for cruiser bikes, this is versatile and works with different model bikes.

And as expected for a universal saddle, it installs on standard seat posts with the installation process itself is a joy thanks to the provided Zacro wrench.

Features 

  • Dual-density gel foam padding
  • Soft and elastic
  • Coil dual spring suspensions (carbon steel)
  • Universal design
  • Polyurethane(PU) material

Pros

  • The saddle fits a bigger number of models and is super-easy to install.
  • This bike saddle delivers admirable comfort to your back when on long rides.
  • Despite being a huge improvement over stock seats, it’s affordably priced.
  • This saddle doesn’t come imprinted with irritating marks or logos like most of its peers.

Cons

  • The Zacro gel saddle isn’t waterproof.

Verdict

With soft but strong materials, the Zacro gel saddle provides the long-sought-after comfort to your back. The Coil dual spring suspensions also help smoother bumps and prevent you from getting sore.

4. Bell Comfort Bike Seat: Most Comfortable Bike Seat for Mountain Bike Overweight Riders

Bell Comfort Bike Seat
856 Reviews
Bell Comfort Bike Seat

  • Soft touch foam padding.
  • Wide, comfortable design.
  • Pressure relieving comfort Channel.
  • Soft ride elastomer suspension.
  • Clamp (included)

The biggest winner here is that this awesome Bell Comfort Bike Seat is lockable and so unlike the other 3 saddles, it’s going to be always on the bike and can’t be forgotten.

Even better, you no longer have the risk of the saddle being stolen.

Aside from that, it’s solid, sturdy and feels very cushy without being overly large as to look embarrassing.
The bike is unisex hence regularly mentioned in the same breath as the best bike saddle for overweight female.

And whatever your bike, the seat exceeds expectations with the elastomer suspension working in tandem with its padding and the leather material to ensure you don’t slide while riding.

The wide design allows free movement among your legs significantly boosting your pedaling efficiency while expertly absorbing the pressure exerted by the seat bones.

It adjusts easily so it should fit your body precisely, has a narrower front, and therefore doesn’t interfere with your high cadence pedaling.

Features 

  • Extra wide
  • Synthetic leather cover
  • Elastomer suspension
  • Clamp (included)
  • Red light

Pros

  • The synthetic leather cover is not only durable but also ensures that your butt will never hurt even if you ride a lot.
  • By going on/off automatically, the red light makes you visible at night enhancing your safety when riding in busy highways.
  • It dries up quickly after drenched, for example, during a storm.
  • Good price

Cons

  • Compared with the largest bike seat available, this seat isn’t that big in size and may, therefore, look smaller for some the biggest guys.

Verdict

This seat’s shape, larger surface, soft padding and suspension make it perfect for heavy riders.

It’s also sturdy as well as being lockable.

Get the most comfortable bicycle seat cover to add thrill and comfort to your ride.

5. Sunlite Cloud-9 Cruiser Saddle: Best for Cruising

Sunlite Cloud-9 Cruiser Saddle
  • Cruiser bicycle saddle designed for serious comfort
  • Dual-density gel foam padding is soft and forgiving
  • Chrome coil spring suspension helps smooth out bumps
  • Universal design installs on any standard seat post
  • Measures 10-1/2 inches long by 10-1/2 inches wide

If you are looking for the most refined cruiser saddle, nothing is as practical as the Sunlite Cloud-9 Cruiser Saddle.

We like most things about this comfortable bike seat for overweight men and women.

For starters, the cruiser seat comes in a wide ergonomic shape to give you optimal comfort.

It promises to retain its shape while also promoting maximum relaxation. That’s thanks to its dual gel foam padding.

And to ensure that you ride smoothly on bumpy roads, the bike seat features chrome coil spring suspension.

Sunlite Cloud-9 promises to fit on any standard bike, owing to its universal fit. Plus, it has a decent airflow channel that promotes cool air circulation and riding comfort.

The concern is that the cushioning may feel extra soft for overweight riders who like moderate padding.

Features

  • Ergonomic shape
  • Dual-density gel foam padding
  • Chrome coil spring suspension
  • Universal fit
  • Airflow channel

Pros

  • Richly comfortable
  • Matches standard bikes
  • Breathable
  • Absorbs shock
  • Waterproof seat cover

Cons

  • The cushioning may feel extra soft

Verdict

Comfort-wise, the Sunlite Cloud-9 Cruiser Saddle doesn’t disappoint. It’s the perfect all-around replacement bike seat for all genders.

6. Giddy Up! Bike Seat: Best for Shock Absorption

Sunlite Cloud-9 Cruiser Saddle
  • PREMIUM COMPLETE BUNDLE ---- COMFORTABLE BIKE SEAT WITH TAIL LIGHT including...
  • SHOCK ABSORBING BALL, MEMORY FOAM MATERIAL and WATERPROOF ---- Looking for a...
  • YOUR SAFETY COMES FIRST ---- Giddy Up! Bike seat comes with a LED TAIL LIGHT and...
  • UNIVERSAL FIT and EASY TO INSTALL ---- Giddy Up! Bicycle seat has a universal...
  • NO RISK PURCHASE ---- Making you a happy customer is our main goal. Just try it,...

The Giddy Up Bike Seat exemplifies shock absorption. So, if there is a perfect bike seat to use on bumps, potholes, and all manner of outdoor ruggedness, this is the one.

The seat features two powerful shock-absorbing rubber balls that enable you to have a smoother ride over rugged terrain.

As if that’s not enough, it’s generously padded with memory foam to feel comfortable under your butt.

Giddy Up Bike Seat also comes with a bright LED taillight and an influential reflective band that makes you visible at night. So, it’s also a decent choice for night cycling.

Its outer cover is waterproof and dust-resistant to allow you to use the seat in all kinds of outdoors. This is one of the most comfortable bike seat for overweight riders we’ve found, and comes with a universal fit. Plus, it is generally stress-free to install.

The primary concern is that the seat may feel slightly firmer for some overweight riders.

Features

  • Shock-absorbing rubber balls
  • Thick memory foam
  • LED taillight
  • Reflective band
  • Universal fit
  • Weatherproof covering

Pros

  • Safe for night cycling
  • Absorbs shock off-road
  • Thick foam padding
  • Easy to install
  • Weather-resistant

Cons

  • Slightly firmer

Verdict

Given that the Giddy Up Bike Seat has powerful shock-absorbing rubber balls, it’s the best to use off-road. If you are not doing heavy-duty biking, this might be overkill.

7. Bikeroo Bike Seat for Women: Best for Overweight Women

Bikeroo Bike Seat for Women
  • Comfort: Ride off into the sunset on a thick padded cushion supported by dual...
  • Universal Replacement: Regardless of what make or model you ride, this bike seat...
  • Works On Exercise Bike: Spend a lot of time spinning? Would your workout last...
  • Complete Installation Kit: This mountain bike seat cushion comes with an...
  • Gift: Know anyone who spends more time peddling on their bike than they do on...

Bikeroo doesn’t disappoint again when it comes to their new, most comfortable bike seat for ladies. The Bikeroo Bike Seat for Women is everything plus-size women want in a saddle.

The seat has thick cushioning to feel extra comfortable. Bikeroo has included a dual-spring suspension to enable the bike seat to absorb shock when cycling off-road.

The saddle enjoys a broader design, which conforms to the women’s anatomy. Its ergonomic shape relieves inter-thigh pressure, and it’s hollow at the center to facilitate cool air circulation.

This bicycle seat comes in an easy-to-mount universal fit to suit most standard bikes.

I only wish the color choices were not so limited.

Features

  • Thick padding
  • Dual spring suspension
  • Ergonomic shape
  • Universal fit
  • Easy to mount

Pros

  • Feels very comfortable
  • Absorbs shock off-road
  • Easy to fit
  • Breathable

Cons

  • Limited color choices

Verdict

The Bikeroo Most Comfortable Bike Seat has the shape and design of a perfect women’s bike seat. As a plus-size woman, the dual-spring suspension will come in handy to minimize discomfort. Especially if you are planning to ride off-road, this is a great option.

8. YLG Oversized Comfort Bike Seat: Alternative Pick for Overweight Women

YLG Oversized Comfort Bike Seat
  • SUPER COMFORTABLE BIKE SADDLE: Padded with premium quality high elasticity high...
  • ERGONOMIC DESIGN BIKE SEAT: Extra arc wide design like a wing fits your hips...
  • STRONG SHOCK ABSORPTION SPRING DUAL:Dual spring rubber ball suspension in the...
  • UNIVERSAL FIT AND EASY TO INSTALL: YLG BIKE SADDLE is designed to fit for almost...
  • UNITED STATES DESIGN PATENT BIKE SADDLE: Our Company is commited to design and...

Any plus-size woman who prioritizes shock-absorption and comfort should consider the YLG Oversized Comfort Bike Seat.

This is one of the most comfortable bike seats for overweight riders, and it comes in an extra-arc wide design to resemble wings. This unique shape was designed to give you optimal comfort.

Its outer covering is waterproof PVC leather, which is also non-slip and wear-resistant.

The seat is made from premium quality high-density foam and gel cushioning to feel extra comfortable.

It also features a dual spring rubber ball that enables it to absorb shock on bumpy roads. The spring, however, may get loose, and that may make the seat extra bouncy.

The bike seat comes in an easy-to-install fit to suit all standard bikes.

Features

  • Non-slip, wear-resistant PVC leather
  • Foam and gel padding
  • Wing-like Ergonomic design
  • Shock-absorption dual spring
  • Universal fit

Pros

  • Easy to install
  • It fits most standard bikes
  • Non-slip and wear-resistant
  • Absorbs shock
  • Highly comfortable.

Cons

  • The spring can become loose

Verdict

YLG Oversized Comfort Bike Seat comes in the perfect design to match a woman’s anatomy. So, it’s a decent choice for plus-size women, especially if comfort is important for you. However, the saddle is on the larger side, especially on something like a mountain bike. So if aesthetics are important to you, a smaller saddle like the Bikeroo might be preferable.

9. DAWAY C99 Bike Seat: Best for Night Cycling

DAWAY C99 Bike Seat
3,083 Reviews
DAWAY C99 Bike Seat
  • 👍SOFT, ELASTIC, NON-SLIP, WEAR-RESISTANT - the best protection of the hip!...
  • 👍WITH WATERPROOF BRIGHT TAIL LIGHT UNIQUE DESIGN - more eye-catching & safety...
  • 👍ERGONOMIC, DUAL SPRING & HOLLOW BREATHABLE DESIGN - enjoy healthy & happy...
  • 👍UNIVERSAL DESIGN, BIKE SEAT RAIL CLAMP INCLUDED - as picture shows, 7/8"...
  • 👍HIGH QUALITY, PROFESSIONAL CUSTOMER SERVICE - If this soft bike saddle...

Do you occasionally ride at night? The DAWAY C99 Unisex Bike Seat is a great option.

It enjoys a universal fit and comes padded with high-quality memory foam to feel comfortable. It’s also extra wide, a trait that also improves its comfort.

On its outer is PVC leather that is soft, elastic, and waterproof. Even the LED light is waterproof to allow you to continue riding when it’s raining.

Impressively, the LED light can run for 36 hours, and it provides you with three lighting settings.

DAWAY C99 comes in an ergonomic shape, featuring a hollow middle that improves its aeration and comfort.

Moreover, it has a dual spring suspension that absorbs shock when riding over bumps. So, it’s perfect for mountain bikes.

A concern I’d have is the PVC leather that doesn’t look durable. Also, with any LED attached light, there can be malfunctions that you need to account for.

Features

  • Universal fit
  • Wide and padded
  • Dual spring suspension
  • Soft, waterproof PVC leather
  • LED taillight with three lighting modes

Pros

  • Allows you to be visible at night
  • It comes with thick padding
  • Protective and weather-resistant cover
  • Shock-absorption
  • Compatible with most bikes

Cons

  • The PVC leather cover is not durable
  • Issues with light are possible

Verdict

Given that this mountain bike seat is made for big guys and gals, and it comes with a three-mode LED tail light, it’s perfect for night cycling. Also, we recommend this bike if you need a little grip on your seat and are prone to sliding off your seat when you ride.

10. Brooks England B17 Bike Saddle: Best Handmade Saddle for Cyclists

Sale
Brooks England B17 Bike Saddle
1,486 Reviews
Brooks England B17 Bike Saddle
  • HANDMADE IN ENGLAND- Manufactured using 100 year old traditional techniques and...
  • SPORT CYCLIST PREFERRED – The B17 has long been the first choice of sporting...
  • NATURAL VENTILATION- The pores of the vegetable tanned leather give the B17...
  • COMFORTABLE DURABILITY- The chrome frame, stainless steel rivets and black steel...
  • TOURING BAG ACCESSIBLE- The seat bag loop in the back is a perfect match for...

When it comes to handmade bike seats, especially for cyclists, very few are as impressive as the Brooks England B17 Bike Saddle.

Hand-made in England, the Brooks England is built from the finest tanned leather to promote long-term use.

Banking on its chrome frame and steel rails, the bike seat can hold huge weights. It’s a great bicycle seat for, say, a 300 pound man who is also a cyclist.

We also enjoy the trendy, sporty look that makes it a perfect choice for those who are looking for a sleeker, customized feel to their saddle.

The seat has several air channels that facilitate natural ventilation. So, you get to feel cooler as you cycle long-distance.

The icing on the cake is the seat bag loop on its back for attaching your English-style biking tour bag. Moreover, it comes with a two-year extended warranty.

The downside is that the seat requires a more extended break-in period because of the leather construction. But once you get over that initial period of discomfort, which is normal, it will be well worth it.

And to help the process along, you might consider getting their proofride leather conditioner.

Features

  • Tanned leather covering
  • Strong chrome frame
  • Natural ventilation
  • Seat bag loop
  • Ergonomic shape

Pros

  • Comfortable once you break it in
  • Strong construction
  • Easy to mount
  • Two-year extended warranty

Cons

  • Longer break-in period

Verdict

The Brooks England B17 might have a more extended break-in period, but its extremely comfortable in the long run. The handmade seat is an ideal choice if you are planning on logging a ton of miles. Expect a 1000 mile or so break in period or so.

11. Asani Oversized Comfort Bike Seat: Best for Back Ache

Asani Oversized Comfort Bike Seat
1,222 Reviews
Asani Oversized Comfort Bike Seat
  • DESIGNED FOR EXTRA COMFORT: Unlike other bike saddles that are too thin, too...
  • UNIVERSAL FIT: No more getting stuck with an ill-fitting replacement bike seat....
  • ISO CERTIFIED QUALITY: Premium materials meet detail-oriented workmanship to...
  • SIMPLE TO INSTALL: You'll have this outdoor/spin bike seat replacement up and...
  • LIFETIME WARRANTY: You have nothing to lose. Our bicycle seat cushion saddle is...

The Asani Oversized Comfort Bike Seat comes in a perfect wide size to give you optimal comfort. If pure comfort is your goal, this is a great choice.

This cycling seat features dual spring suspension and has soft padding, making it perfect for back pain.

It comes in a universal fit, which makes it perfect for cruisers, tour bikes, mountain bikes, stationary bikes, among many others.

The Asani is one of the more comfortable bike seats for overweight riders and is simple to install, and you can do it tool-free. Moreover, it comes with a lifetime warranty.

There are a few issues with this bike seat we’ve found however. On higher speed it can be a little too “springy” and cause discomfort. Also, if you are night cycling, remember that this seat doesn’t feature an LED taillight. You would have to go with something like the Daway C99 for that option.

Features

  • Extra-wide
  • Premium material
  • Thick padding
  • Universal fit
  • Tool-free installation

Pros

  • Lifetime warranty
  • Simple to install
  • Compatible with most bike seat posts
  • Durable construction
  • Feels very comfortable
  • Great for back pain

Cons

  • Lacks an LED tail light
  • Can be a little too “springy” at high speeds
  • Can be creaky over time

Verdict

Overall, the Asani Oversized Comfort Bike Seat is perfect for overweight riders with back problems. It’s soft-padded and very, very wide. The metal springs, however, do lend itself to creaking over time, so keep this in mind. But if pure comfort is your goal, we’d give this saddle a shot.

12. Fizik Aliante Gamma Cycling Saddle: Best Racing Saddle

Fizik Aliante Gamma Cycling Saddle
95 Reviews
Fizik Aliante Gamma Cycling Saddle

  • Rail: Kium; Shell: Carbon reinforced nylon.
  • Dimensions 266 x 141 mm.
  • Features integrated clip system compatible. It weighs 0.57 pounds.
  • Twin Flex Technology.
  • Road Saddle.

Very few road racing saddles are as ergonomic as the Fizik Aliante Gamma Cycling Saddle. Fizik has a well-earned reputation in the industry for both comfort and durability, so in general you will get a quality saddle with a Fizik.

As with any Fizik, you should do the test described in this video to find out what animal you are. This particular model is for “bulls”, or people who are less flexible.

Now that you’ve done the test, you’ll know if this Italian handmade saddle is right for you.

We like the narrow nose, which reduce friction with your thighs and increases comfort. Also, its shell is carbon-reinforced nylon, which maintains its ergonomic shape.

This cycling saddle is only 0.57 pounds, thus relatively lightweight to suit road racing. However if weight is super important to you, the Aliante R1 model is newer and lighter at 0.40 pounds.

And as we’ve said before, the Fizik Aliante Gamma is handmade for cyclists with a rigid spine and those with an inflexible low back. In other words, “bulls” according to their system.

If you are extremely flexible, we suggest going with the Arione R1.

The primary issue with this road saddle is it may feel slightly firm. And also make sure you are fine with the black and white design.

Features

  • Lightweight design
  • Braided-carbon rails
  • Carbon-reinforced nylon shell
  • Narrow nose

Pros

  • Great for racing
  • Lightweight
  • Strong construction
  • Durable

Cons

  • Feels slightly firm
  • Black and white design not right for everyone

Verdict

The Fizik Aliante Gamma Cycling Saddle is lightweight and a great option for less flexible riders. The best part besides its robust construction if that this is a versatile saddle. If you ride in more of an upright position and are looking for a higher end saddle, Fizik is always a great choice.

Compared to other Fizik models, this will come with more padding. So for bigger guys and gals, this is a solid saddle.

How You Ride and Comfort

We don’t want you to think that having the right bike seat is the only thing that matters as an overweight rider. Although the type of bicycle seat you get is critical for comfort, how you ride your bike is arguably just as important.

In this vein, we always recommend that you talk to a fitting professional in general. It will be one of the better $100 or $200 dollars you spend.

After you get fitted, make sure you ride back on your seat towards the more cushiony part. Many riders make the mistake of ridging too far up in the skinnier part of their saddle, leading to discomfort.

Even if you do everything right, long days (in the saddle) and bumps are can cause what’s called perineum compression. The perineum is the area between the groin and anus, and it is a highly vulnerable area when riding.

Perineum compression can cause nerve damage, swelling, and a lot of pain, so it’s important to prevent this if possible.

Besides a nice and comfortable seat, some things you can do to alleviate perineum compression are:

  • Stand up for a few seconds on your pedals each 10 minutes.
  • Go for a full-suspension bike (and of course, the most comfortable mountain bike seat) or hunt for a suspension seatpost (found on some commuting and recreational bikes).
  • Stand slightly when negotiating bumps, effectively making your legs shock absorbers.
  • Switch to the best recumbent bike.

Types of Bike Seats for Heavy Riders

There are various types of saddles to choose from, each based on a different style of riding. What is the right bike seat for you depends on what kind of bike riding you prefer.

That being said, here are the most common types of bike seats.

Cruiser Saddles

Cruiser saddles are known for their generous cushioning and considerable support.

Their upright handlebars (which make them so comfortable) ensure that most of your weight falls directly on the typically large bike seat.

Another advantage is that cruising doesn’t demand aggressive pedaling meaning that with the additional support, these heavily padded saddles remains comfortable.

Here is my favorite cruiser saddle for overweight riders: Sunlite Cloud-9 Cruiser Saddle

Comfort Saddles

Comfort saddles are the other top bike seats.

They also have lots of padding and memory foam in addition to being designed to facilitate easy pedaling.

Comfort saddles are the best for long distance tours and are great in absorbing shock and vibrations common in rough roads.

This is my recommendation: Bikeroo Most Comfortable Bike Seat for Women

Racing Saddles

Racing saddles have a “sleeker” design and are made to permit full movement and eliminate chafing.

They shift you forward such that more of your weight is on your hands (and feet) and not on the seat.

We even have racing saddles purposely developed to protect your reproductive organs!

In my opinion, Fizik is the saddle of choose if you are a racer. My favorite? The Fizik Road Bicycle Saddle

If you want more great information on saddles and how to find the right one, take a look at this video.

More Tips on Finding the Most Comfortable Bike Seat for Overweight Riders

Test Ride

No doubt, nothing beats test riding with all your candidates for the best bike seat.

The best part is that many stores will have options closer to what you’re looking for even if not the exact model so try them.

Remember to vary positions, speed, and try hitting some bumps to get a feel of what to expect.

Measure your Saddle Width

Another important consideration is the correct saddle width. I’ve mentioned before that saddle width is dependent on your “seat bone”

By and large, women have wider bottoms than men who have their seat bones positioned much closer together, which is why women’s saddles are on the whole a bit wider than men’s.

While most bike shops will be able to measure your seat bones, you can also get a pretty accurate measure yourself. Here is great video on how to measure your sit bone at home:


FAQs

How Do I Choose A Bike Seat?

You have to factor in several things when choosing a bike seat. Here are a few ground rules:

  • Comfort comes first. So, the seat should have ample padding and shock-absorption and should be of the correct width.
  • For added comfort you can look for a high density memory foam seat. Often found on mattresses, high density memory foam may be the best option if you are an overweight rider.
  • Ventilation is paramount. So, look for a breathable seat to cool your butt area when things overheat due to friction.
  • The covering should be water-resistant, scratch-resistant, stain-proof, and tear-resistant.
  • The rails and the shell should be strong to maintain the seat’s shape.
  • Additionally, consider things like saddle shape, cut-out, and cost.

Why Is My Bike Seat Uncomfortable?

If you feel uncomfortable shortly after you start cycling, the chances are that your saddle or seat post is misaligned.

But still, it could be that the saddle doesn’t fit or that its design is just off. In either case, the saddle is wrong, and so you should consider changing it.

How Do I Stop My Bike Seat From Hurting?

You can stop your bike seat from hurting using these tips:

  • Look for a more seat cover to use on your current bike
  • Replace your existing seat cover with a more comfortable option
  • Wear biking shorts to improve your butt comfort
  • Stand up periodically when you cycle
  • Use emollient cream to soothe the hurting area
  • Engage your core when riding
  • Consider a bike seat with memory foam

Is A Wider Saddle Better?

Wider seats offer the most comfort in most cases. But always get fitted so you know your seat bone width, and hence, the ideal seat width for your individual body.

Excessively wide saddles, especially on the saddle’s nose area, might cause your thighs to rub against it, resulting in friction and discomfort.

How Wide Should My Bike Saddle Be?

Generally, wider seats are more comfortable than narrow ones. However, the width shouldn’t be too extensive.

In this case, the wisest approach is to add 2 cm to your seat bones’ spacing. Doing so protects you from having to sit on the edges of the metal frame.

Recap

Because of the excess pressure and weight, heavy riders are frequently forced to replace their bike seats. This is why it’s so important to do research on the most comfortable bike seat for overweight riders.

As an overweight rider, you generally want soft padding, a wide seat, and spring suspensions. But again, every body is different and getting fitted is always the best option.

And finally, make sure you test out different saddles in person if at all possible. Nothing beats actually feeling what is the most comfortable for your particular body.

Related Posts
Related Posts
Trending